Divya and her brother invested on the same day. She is a doctor in London, originally from Coimbatore, and put ₹9.4 lakh into a Nifty 50 index fund.
He works at a Bengaluru startup and began a ₹17,500 monthly SIP in a Nifty 50 Equal Weight fund.
Both assumed they had bought the same 50 companies. They had. What they had not bought was the same portfolio.
The Nifty 50 vs Nifty 50 Equal Weight choice comes down to one risk, which is concentration.
In a year when the largest banks and technology names lead, her fund pulls ahead.
In a year when the other forty do the work, his does.
Same 50 companies, two different bets
What separates the two indices? Only the weights.
The Nifty 50 weights each company by its free-float market value, so bigger companies get bigger shares.
The equal weight version gives every company the same share at each reset. Axis Mutual Fund's comparison of the two indices sets out the method.
NSE's own white paper on the equal weight index explains why it was created.
Index investing is new to many readers.
Our primers on what stock market indices are and market capitalisation cover the basics.
The risk hiding inside a Nifty 50 fund
Is a 50-stock index fund diversified? By count, yes. By weight, less than it looks.
A handful of companies carry a large part of the Nifty 50. The top ten have made up more than half of the index in recent factsheets.
The bottom ten together barely register.
Sector weights follow the same pattern.
Financial services and technology companies are among the largest in India, so they dominate the index too. NSE Indices publishes current weights in its factsheets at niftyindices.com.
None of this is a flaw. A market-value index is meant to mirror the market, and the market is top-heavy. The point is to know what you own.
We often meet investors who hold a Nifty 50 fund, a Sensex fund and a large-cap active fund.
They believe that is three kinds of diversification. In practice, the same heavyweight stocks sit at the top of all three.
Our article on diversification versus concentration explains why the number of holdings is a poor guide.
How concentration shows up in your returns
Where would you notice it? On days when one or two giants move sharply.
Take an illustrative case. A company with a 10% weight falls 20% on bad results. That alone pulls the index down by about 2%.
The same company in an equal weight index has roughly a 2% weight. Its 20% fall costs the index about 0.4%. The other 49 companies matter far more.
This cuts both ways. When the giants rally, the Nifty 50 captures more of it. The equal weight index gives the same credit to a mid-sized cement maker as to the largest bank.
There is a practical side for anyone who watches pre-market signals.
GIFT Nifty tracks the market-value Nifty 50, not the equal weight version. So the GIFT Nifty live tracker tells you more about Divya's fund than her brother's.
On mornings when the GIFT Nifty chart points sharply one way, the move is often led by heavyweights.
An equal weight fund can open the day looking quite different. Our explainer on GIFT Nifty versus the Nifty 50 covers how the two relate.
How large is the difference over time?
Does equal weight win in the long run? The history is mixed, and it depends heavily on the period you pick.
DSP Mutual Fund's white paper on the equal weight index found it ahead of the Nifty 50 over long stretches. Recent trailing figures have also favoured equal weight. Fund house pages show the current numbers.
The pattern behind those figures matters more than the figures. Equal weight tends to lead in broad rallies, when many companies rise together.
It tends to lag in narrow markets led by a few giants.
Axis Mutual Fund says as much on its equal weight fund page. It notes that the approach may underperform during narrow rallies.
Those phases can last years, not months.
Watch for: switching to whichever index tops the one-year chart. That is performance chasing with an index label on it. Our guide to rolling returns versus point-to-point returns shows a fairer way to compare.
Equal weight removes one risk and adds others
Is equal weight simply the safer Nifty? No. It swaps concentration risk for three other things.
The first is a tilt towards smaller companies.
Equal weight gives the fiftieth company the same say as the first. So the portfolio behaves more like the average Nifty company, which is smaller and often more volatile.
The second is a built-in habit of selling winners.
Every quarter, stocks that rose are trimmed and stocks that fell are topped up. Aditya Birla Sun Life AMC's explainer on the equal weight index fund describes this reset.
The third is turnover. All that trimming and topping up means more trading inside the fund. More trading means more cost, which we come to next.
A year in the life of each index looks like this.
Tata Mutual Fund's note on Nifty 50 rebalancing explains how companies enter and leave.
A newly listed company cannot join straight after its IPO. It has to meet listing and size criteria first.
Companies listed only on GIFT City exchanges are a separate universe. A GIFT City IPO does not feed into either of these indices.
Costs and tracking
Which one is cheaper to own? Usually the plain Nifty 50 fund.
Nifty 50 index funds are among the lowest-cost equity funds in India. Equal weight funds tend to charge a little more and trade more.
Check each fund's current expense ratio on the fund house website.
Tracking matters as much as cost.
An index fund's job is to match its index, and the gap is called tracking error. Quarterly resets give an equal weight fund more chances to slip.
Our guides to ETF tracking error and expense ratio versus tracking error explain how to read both numbers.
They were written for US ETFs, but the logic is the same.
Check first: compare a fund's return with its own index over three years or more. A cheap fund that trails its index by a wide margin is not cheap.
Tax and access for NRIs
Are the two taxed differently? No.
Both are equity-oriented funds, and the same capital gains rules apply to each.
For NRIs, tax is deducted at source when units are redeemed. The Income Tax Department's note on taxation of non-residents gives the framework. Belong's tax filing service helps NRIs claim credit for that deduction.
Access is the practical hurdle. NRIs invest through NRE or NRO accounts, and some fund houses restrict investors from certain countries. Confirm that before choosing a fund on cost alone.
Hedging is another difference.
The liquid derivatives are built on the Nifty 50. Investors who use GIFT Nifty futures or other futures and options get a closer match for a Nifty 50 holding.
Which one fits Divya, and which fits her brother?
What should each of them have chosen? The answer starts with what else they own.
Divya's Indian portfolio is this one fund.
Her savings in the UK are spread across global markets. For her, a Nifty 50 fund is a simple, low-cost anchor for India.
Its concentration is a smaller issue because India is only part of her wealth. She also keeps a separate pot for the down payment on an NRI home loan. That money is not in equity at all.
Her brother's position is different. Much of his net worth sits in ESOPs of one company. He already carries concentration risk, so an equal weight fund is a reasonable counterweight.
He did two sensible things before starting.
He cleared a balance on one of his credit cards. He also checked his CIBIL score ahead of a future loan.
His bigger gap is geography. Everything he owns depends on India. Our guide to investing in the USA from India is the natural next read.
So is our piece on why a portfolio needs more than just India.
Holding both funds is also a fair answer. A split leaves you less exposed to the giants without betting fully against them. It does add a fund to track, so keep the reason clear.
Neither index replaces a decision about size segments. Mid-sized and smaller companies sit outside both.
See large cap versus mid cap versus small cap and our list of large-cap mutual funds.
Readers still choosing between passive and active can start with index funds versus actively managed funds. Our roundup of index mutual funds covers the wider menu.
Where GIFT City funds fit
Can either index be held in dollars?
Rupee index funds cannot. GIFT City funds can offer India and global exposure in dollars, though they are not index trackers of this kind.
Belong is regulated by IFSCA in GIFT City, and our licences are listed here. The GIFT City mutual funds screener is a quick way to see what is available alongside a rupee index fund. Examples include:
Tata India Dynamic Equity Fund, for Indian equity
Sundaram India Mid Cap Fund, for mid-sized Indian companies
DSP Global Equity Fund, for global shares
Edelweiss Greater China Equity Fund, for a single-region view
These can be bought through a mutual funds platform. Larger investors can also look at GIFT City alternative investment funds.
Equity is one side of a portfolio. For the steadier side, our NRI FD rates tool compares deposits, including USD fixed deposits. The guide to GIFT City, FCNR, NRE and NRO deposits explains the differences.
Residents weighing a similar choice abroad face the same trade-off. The S&P 500 is also top-heavy, as our guide to investing in the S&P 500 from India notes. The risks of staying home-only are covered in investing only in Indian markets.
Download the Belong app to keep the GIFT Nifty tracker and your dollar holdings in one place. The weekly GIFT Nifty outlook and past GIFT Nifty data add context on how the heavyweights are moving.
FAQs
Is the Nifty 50 Equal Weight index riskier than the Nifty 50?
It carries different risk. It is less exposed to any single company and more exposed to the smaller names in the index. Its swings can be larger in weak markets.
Can NRIs invest in Nifty 50 Equal Weight index funds?
Generally, yes, through NRE or NRO accounts. Some fund houses restrict investors based in certain countries. Check the fund's eligibility terms before you apply.
Do both funds hold exactly the same companies?
Yes. The equal weight index uses the Nifty 50 list and follows its entries and exits. Only the weights differ.
Is it sensible to switch from one to the other?
Only for a reason that will still hold in five years. A switch is a redemption and a fresh purchase. That means tax today, plus TDS for NRIs.
A question to answer for yourself
If India's five largest companies had a bad decade, how much of your portfolio would you want riding on them?
Sources
NSE Indices, index factsheets and methodology
Axis Mutual Fund, Nifty 50 vs Nifty50 Equal Weight: key differences
Axis Mutual Fund, Axis Nifty50 Equal Weight Index Fund
DSP Mutual Fund, Nifty50 Equal Weight Index white paper
Aditya Birla Sun Life AMC, What is the Nifty 50 Equal Weight Index Fund
Tata Mutual Fund, How does the Nifty 50 rebalance
Income Tax Department, Taxation of Non-Resident
Disclaimer
This article is for general information and education. It is not investment, tax or legal advice. Rules, rates and limits change, so please check the linked official sources and speak to a qualified adviser before you act.
